I'm a little late to this party - well, half a decade late, technically - but I couldn't resist mentioning what a great book "Down to This" by Shaughnessy Bishop-Stall is. The book, for those of you who either haven't read it or don't know about it, describes his experience living in Tent City, the shanty that sprang up on Home Depot's then-undeveloped lot down on the waterfront. But this isn't a book about the politics of homelessness, and it's not about a privileged guy parachuting himself into a difficult situation in order to artificially extract insight and information (which, I confess, is what I thought it was before reading it.)
Instead, it's an immaculate piece of writing, blending the energy of Kerouac's "On the Road" with the exquisite attention to detail of Orwell's "Down and Out in Paris and London." It's a book that doesn't pull any punches but also gives the people with whom he shared almost a year of his life in tent city the dignity and attention they deserve. Sure, many of them are drug addicts, some of them are prostitutes, and all of them have some major form of social dysfunction, but they're also interesting and complex people with needs and desires that aren't all that different from yours or mine. One of the most interesting things Bishop-Stall accomplishes is to treat a group of people - the homeless, broadly writ - like the diverse group of individuals that they are, a need that is almost as important as food and shelter.
Then there's the humour, which you wouldn't expect in a book dominated by scenes of deprivation, humiliation, violence, and poverty. There's his goldfish, Dude, who dies of a crack overdose after one of Bishop-Stall's pals gives him some figurines to put in the tank that, he later discovered, were covered in crack resin. Or there's the time where Jackie, the first person he met in Tent City, waves off her diagnosis of Lyme Disease by proclaiming that she will simply avoid eating citrus fruits for the forseeable future. Most of this is black comedy, to be sure, but it's there all the same.
I could go on for pages here, and I won't. Suffice it to say that anybody reading this who hasn't bought the book should go do so. But I think, before I go, it's important to make an observation about what this book says about the state of literature in Canada. That it hasn't received the acclaim it deserves - and it has received acclaim, mind you - is indicative of the fact that it doesn't conform to the prevailing standard of Canadian literature, of bucolic scenes of quiet angst, preferably in a rural setting and, if possible, at least fifty years ago. His, in contrast, is gritty, urbane, and unpretentious - hell, half of the protagonists, if you can call them that, are crackheads who routinely steal, fight, and abuse other human beings. But that's the beauty of Bishop-Stall's book; it's real.
More importantly, he doesn't hide from that reality or the often unpleasant aspects of it. He doesn't proselytize about homelessness and he doesn't trade in the cheap stereotypes and anti-government propaganda that so many anti-poverty advocates rely upon, some of whom show up as well meaning but hopelessly naive characters in his book. Instead, he describes a bunch of particular human beings, each screwed up in their own particular ways, and while that kind of approach might not be conducive to government programs or other top-down fixes it's also the only honest way to approach the situation.
I hope he writes another book soon. I hope that this experience hasn't destroyed him the way it would so many others, too, because he's a great talent.